13 Ways to Promote Your Loyalty Program

While a fifth of consumers switched brands almost as soon as COVID-19 hit, according to McKinsey, “73% of loyalty members shopped more with their favorite retailers during the pandemic,” discovered a 2021 Clarus study. 

Moreover, 90% of participants told Clarus they’d rather buy from “a retailer where they’re a premium loyalty member over another one offering a lower price.”

76% of participants are even willing to pay to join a loyalty program.

So how do you promote your loyalty program and gain all these benefits?

Let’s take a look.


Offer Rewards!

Loyalty is key for longevity, so it deserves rewards.

#1 Reward customers (quickly) for joining your loyalty program

Loyalty programs often give long term rewards, but consider making it worth their while right now. Don’t leave the decision to join to “some day,” which might never come.

If you offer your program during a purchase, give customers a reward they can instantly redeem.

If you suggest joining at other times, create urgency by offering an additional reward that expires within 24 hours.

#2 Give extra loyal customers extra rewards

Make your program tiered, so customers can accumulate points by:

Use a Popup and Your Website Menu

Make the most of your most precious online real estate.

#3 Use a popup in strategic moments to encourage signups

Design your popup to appear when customers are likely to sign up, like when they:

Personalized popup experiences are ideal, say, based on:

Grow your sales with high-performing deals.

#4 Highlight your loyalty program on your top navigation menu

Popups are efficient in highlighting promotions, but don’t overuse them. Highlight your loyalty program on your top navigation menu, and let customers discover it on their own, too.

Remember email marketing

Email might not outlive us, but for now, email marketing is one of the most powerful tools we’ve got.

#5 Using email marketing to nurture leads? Convert them to loyalty program members

If you have a non-buying sector that’s highly engaged with your email marketing efforts – opens every email, clicks links, responds sometimes – consider a soft pitch for your loyalty program.

Similarly, if you see they mostly open discount-focused emails, they might be ready for the buying-incentivizing rewards a loyalty program offers.

6) Send personalized emails to customers who’ve bought and referred, but haven’t signed up yet

Some of your customers are already loyal… they just haven’t signed up to your program yet.

They buy regularly.

They’ve referred friends who also buy from you.

So why bother recruiting them to your loyalty program?

Proactively letting them know about rewards that are available for the activities they do “for free” can add appreciation and tighten their bond with your brand. Giving them some of these rewards retroactively can take it to the next level.

Your loyalty program is the place to nurture this relationship and ensure their advocacy continues.

#7 Nurture loyalty program members through email marketing, then ask them to participate in case studies

Email marketing isn’t just for initial relationship building with folks who’ve gotten that $10 coupon for their first purchase. It can be used to nurture the relationship with your valued loyalty program members.

Once you deepen this relationship, it’ll be easier for you to ask for their participation in case studies. It’s always more reliable when a customer says we’re great than when we say it ourselves. 

When customers let you publish their stories, you can leverage their voice throughout your website, advertising and social media efforts.

Leverage social media

You and your customers are there all day anyway, so sprinkle some promotions.

#8 Adding new benefits to your loyalty program? Running a special promotion? Time for a new post

No one likes to follow a feed that’s constantly promoting products, but if you usually provide value and fun, the occasional promotion will be well accepted.

So post about your loyalty program when you have a concrete – maybe urgent – reason to do so. Say, when you introduce a new reward or run a time-limited discount.

You can also share celebratory posts (for example, when you reach 50,000 members) or customers’ own posts.

#9 Feature related user generated content

As mentioned above, no one is more trustworthy to promote your brand or loyalty program than your customers. They’re your prospects’ peers, they understand prospects’ experiences and hesitations, and they (usually) don’t have much to gain by sharing their stories.

So, encourage customers to share content related to your program, and tag you, including:

#10 Answer customer questions about your program

If you constantly get the same questions about your loyalty program, answer them on your feed every once in a while. Even better, provide personalized answers to questions you get from followers:

Encourage Referrals

When your customers recommend you, you know you’re doing something good. And you know that the new leads they generate for you will come trusting, ready to buy.

#11 Reward referrals

Our recommendation is to provide two rewards per referral:

It’s a win-win.

#12 Create referral-encouraging experiences

Look for ways to connect friends, family members or stranger-but-like-minded customers through your loyalty program. This way, customers will have a deeper reason than discounts or store credit to refer their loved ones – they’ll have an opportunity to build social and family connections.

For example:

#13 Ask customers why they haven’t referred their friends yet

Getting feedback from current members will help you adjust your rewards to encourage more referrals – and to serve your current customers better.

Maybe the loyalty program doesn’t actually serve their needs, so they can’t recommend it yet.

Maybe the program is great, but they forgot they signed up because you haven’t implemented a nurturing email marketing program yet. They haven’t fully experienced its benefits yet, so they can’t refer others to it.

Make changes, report back to show customers you care, and get more feedback to keep growing.

Bonus Tip: Close the Gaps

Feedback from customers is the most important information you can get. If there’s a gap between what you create for them and what they need, no amount of promotion will help.

Combine their qualitative feedback with data-based tools to get a bigger picture, since not everybody will give you feedback. Closing your tech stack gap can also give you better tools to personalize and scale your promotions… as well as to analyze what your competitors are doing.

Understanding what competitors are offering and how they promote their loyalty programs will help you realize the industry standard. But just as importantly, combined with your data, it will help you see the gap competitors have left open.

It will help you be the one that closes the gap for your customers, and serves their needs best. Once you do that, they’ll likely do more of the promotion for you.

If you’re looking for more Shopify tips and recommendations, check out the PickyStory blog.

Good Luck!

Grow your sales with high-performing deals.

Generate more revenue from every store visit.

Offer irresistible deals across your buyer's journey.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin



Schedule a call to learn more about PickyStory's e-commerce conversion platform

By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from PickyStory.

Trusted by the fastest-growing e-commerce brands


Convert more visitors into buyers with PickyStory's e-commerce conversion platform

By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from PickyStory.

Trusted by the fastest-growing e-commerce brands

Receive the latest updates from PickyStory, right to your inbox.

By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from PickyStory