[New Era] Bundles AI: Auto-generate & sell the best performing bundles 🤖

Watch now
pickystory
Start free

Magento vs Shopify Plus: Pros, Cons, and Key Differences [Complete Guide]

  • 5 minutes
Table of Contents

In the e-commerce world, even the slightest edge can mean a significant advantage over competitors. That is why large-scale brands look for the best possible e-commerce platform to help them reach their customers worldwide.

But what about small and medium-sized e-commerce sites? These e-commerce sites generally find challenges when looking to scale. As a result, choosing the best e-commerce platform can be a challenge. In this article, we’re going to look at the comparison between Shopify Plus and Magento Enterprise. We’re going to look at how Shopify Plus stacks up against Magento Enterprise, giving you the lowdown on which platform may be the best choice given your online store’s needs and requirements.

So, don’t go anywhere because we have a very interesting discussion coming right up!

What Is Magento?

Magento is an open-source e-commerce platform that allows businesses to create and manage online stores. It was first released in 2008 and has since become one of the most popular e-commerce platforms in the world. Magento provides a flexible and scalable framework for building online stores of all sizes, from small businesses to large enterprises. It offers a wide range of features, including customizable templates, powerful marketing tools, and robust inventory management capabilities. Magento also has a large and active community of developers who contribute to the platform, creating extensions and plugins that enhance its functionality. There are two editions of Magento available: the free community edition and the paid enterprise edition, which offers additional features and support.

What Is Magento Enterprise?

Magento Enterprise (now known as Magento Commerce) is a paid version of the Magento e-commerce platform that offers additional features and support for businesses with more complex needs. It is designed to meet the needs of larger enterprises and high-growth businesses that require a more powerful and scalable e-commerce solution.

Some features distinguishing Magento Commerce from the free community edition include advanced marketing and merchandising tools, business intelligence and analytics, support for multiple storefronts and languages, and 24/7 technical support.

Magento Commerce also offers more flexibility and customization options than the community edition, allowing businesses to tailor their online stores to meet their specific needs. It is typically priced based on the size and complexity of the business, with customized quotes provided by Magento’s sales team.

Adobe commerce compared Shopify Plus mageworx
Source: https://www.mageworx.com/wiki/magento2-cache

Magento Enterprise Pros

Magento Commerce offers a range of advanced features not available in the free community edition of Magento. Here are some of the key features of Magento Commerce:

#1: Advanced Marketing and Merchandising

Magento Commerce provides advanced marketing tools such as targeted promotions, up-sell and cross-sell capabilities, and personalized product recommendations based on customer behavior. It also offers a range of merchandising tools that allow businesses to manage and display their products easily. Magento strives to help large brands get the most out of their marketing endeavors. That is why large brands have preferred Magento over other e-commerce platforms in the past.

#2: Business Intelligence and Analytics

Magento Commerce offers powerful business intelligence and analytics tools that provide insights into customer behavior, sales performance, and website performance. This data can be used to optimize marketing campaigns, improve customer engagement, and increase sales. As such, Magento offers users highly detailed analytics they can use to track their site’s performance.

#3: Multi-Storefront Support

Magento Commerce allows businesses to manage multiple storefronts from a single platform easily. This feature is particularly useful for businesses operating in multiple countries or with different brands or product lines. Multi-storefront support is arguably the biggest factor that draws large brands to Magento. The fact that Magento supports multiple storefronts gives large brands the flexibility to create various storefronts depending on the region they operate.

#4: Enhanced Security

Magento Commerce includes enhanced security features such as two-factor authentication, advanced user permissions, and PCI compliance, which helps protect sensitive customer data and reduce the risk of data breaches. Given data security’s importance, brands and customers need to be certain the e-commerce platform they use offers the latest security measures.

#5: 24/7 Technical Support

Magento Commerce provides 24/7 technical support, ensuring that businesses have access to help whenever they need it. It’s worth noting that large brands may already have a dedicated IT team monitoring the site’s performance. Nevertheless, it’s good to have strong tech support if problems arise within the platform.

#6: Scalability and Performance.

Magento Commerce is designed to handle high traffic and large volumes of transactions, making it suitable for businesses with high-growth needs. Magento is known for its ability to handle large-volume traffic. So, working with a platform equipped to handle significant volume makes sense, particularly when e-commerce sites begin scaling.

#7: Customization and Flexibility.

Magento Commerce provides a high degree of customization and flexibility, allowing businesses to tailor their online stores to meet their specific needs. It’s worth noting that while Magento Commerce integrates with virtually any third-party platform and application, there is a need for careful integrations. This integration process may involve significant amounts of coding and development to ensure that integrations and customizations work as intended.

As you can see, Magento offers businesses several key features. Magento has been the choice for large brands in the past, given its flexibility and highly customizable platform. However, there are important drawbacks to consider, as well. These drawbacks mainly refer to cost, technical complexity, and a steep learning curve. As a result, many large brands looking to cut back on costs have been migrating to more cost-effective and less work-intensive alternatives.

Magento Enterprise Cons

The following drawbacks related to Magento Commerce as worth considering:

#1: Cost

Magento Commerce is a paid platform, and its pricing can be expensive, particularly for small businesses. The cost of the platform varies depending on the size and complexity of the business, and it may not be cost-effective for businesses with smaller budgets.

#2: Complexity

Magento Commerce can be complex and difficult to use for users with limited technical expertise. While the platform offers a high degree of customization and flexibility, this can also make it more challenging to set up and manage.

#3: Technical Requirements

Magento Commerce has specific technical requirements, such as server resources and database configurations, that need to be met to ensure optimal performance. This situation can require a dedicated team with technical expertise to manage.

#4: Maintenance

Magento Commerce requires regular updates and maintenance to ensure it runs smoothly and securely. This condition can be time-consuming and require a dedicated team to manage.

#5: Learning Curve

Magento Commerce has a steep learning curve, particularly for users unfamiliar with the platform or with limited experience with e-commerce. This learning curve can make getting started more difficult and lead to longer setup times. More often than not, Magento users need to hire a professional team to help them set up their e-commerce sites.

On the whole, Magento is not for everyone. It requires specialized knowledge, meaning the average store owner may need to hire dedicated IT professionals to run their e-commerce sites. The technical complexity of running a Magento-based site may prove too much for the average online store owner. That is why a simpler solution, such as Shopify Plus, can help e-commerce site owners find a solid alternative requiring much less investment in time and resources.

Grow your sales with high-performing deals.

Get PickyStory

Comparison Between Magento Enterprise and Shopify Plus

Magento Commerce or Adobe Commerce Hero
Source: https://business.adobe.com/products/magento/magento-commerce.html

Here is a comparison between Shopify Plus and Magento Enterprise across several key areas:

#1: Ease of Use

Shopify Plus has a user-friendly interface that is easy to navigate and set up, even for users with limited technical expertise. Magento Enterprise, on the other hand, can be more complex and requires technical knowledge to set up and manage. In essence, Shopify Plus users can upgrade from a regular Shopify store to a Shopify Plus store without the need for extensive coding and development. While this project may not be a DIY weekend endeavor, a Shopify store owner can venture out independently. In contrast, setting up an e-commerce site on Magento is not a DIY job unless the store owner happens to be an experienced web developer.

#2: Cost

Shopify Plus is a subscription-based platform, with pricing ranging from $2,000 to $40,000 per month, depending on the business size. On the other hand, Magento Enterprise is a one-time purchase with costs ranging from $22,000 to $125,000 or more, depending on the size and complexity of the business. However, the average cost of a Shopify Plus store could range up to $250,000. In comparison, building an online store on Magento Commerce can easily top $500,000. This overall cost consideration makes Shopify Plus a better option for smaller businesses looking to scale.

#3: Customization

Both platforms offer a high degree of customization and flexibility. Still, Magento Enterprise offers more advanced customization options, making it a better choice for businesses with complex requirements. Shopify Plus does offer a fair degree of customization. But for e-commerce sites looking for the best possible degree of customization, Magento offers a better alternative even with the complexity and cost that comes with it.

#4: Performance

Both platforms offer high-performance capabilities, but Shopify Plus is a cloud-based platform optimized for speed and scalability, making it a better choice for businesses requiring high-performance capabilities. Head-to-head, the performance between both sites is comparable. However, there is a key difference between Magento Enterprise and Shopify Plus. Shopify Plus is a cloud-based system meaning that everything is hosted on Shopify’s servers. Magento is a self-hosted site meaning that e-commerce sites would have to invest in their own hosting infrastructure or purchase third-party hosting through a company such as Amazon. Since Magento introduced its cloud version, reviews have been mixed. As a result, more and more users have found Shopify Plus to offer a much more efficient cloud-based solution.

#5: Integrations

Both platforms offer integrations with third-party tools and applications. Still, Shopify Plus offers a wider range of pre-built integrations with popular tools such as Google Analytics and Mailchimp. On the whole, Shopify Plus offers many more third-party integrations than Magento Commerce. But for online store owners looking for a high degree of customization, Magento does offer much more freedom to add customized features.

#5: Support

Both platforms offer support options, but Shopify Plus offers 24/7 support via phone, email, and live chat. In contrast, Magento Enterprise offers support during business hours. It’s worth noting that Shopify strives to deliver the best possible customer service and support. This approach makes Shopify Plus a better option for smaller businesses looking to scale than large-scale companies that may already have a dedicated IT team.

Overall, Shopify Plus is a more user-friendly and scalable platform better suited for businesses with smaller budgets or limited technical expertise. In comparison, Magento Enterprise is better suited for businesses with complex requirements and larger budgets. It is important for businesses to carefully consider their needs and requirements when choosing between these platforms.

Shopify Plus vs. Magento Enterprise

When looking at Shopify Plus vs. Magento Enterprise head-to-head, the specific needs and requirements of your e-commerce site play a significant role in determining which one would be the best option. Both platforms offer powerful features and functionality, but they differ in terms of ease of use, cost, scalability, support, integrations, and other factors.

The first consideration in the Shopify Plus vs. Magento enterprise discussion is scalability. Shopify Plus is a cloud-based platform optimized for speed and scalability, making it a better choice for businesses that need to scale up their operations quickly. Magento Enterprise, on the other hand, may require additional technical expertise and resources to scale up.

Also, budget is an important consideration in the Magento Enterprise vs. Shopify Plus comparison. If your business has a smaller budget or limited technical expertise, Shopify Plus may be a better option as it offers a user-friendly interface, a subscription-based pricing model, and 24/7 support. Shopify Plus is also optimized for speed and scalability, making scaling up your operations easier.

On the other hand, if your e-commerce site requires more advanced customization options or has complex requirements, Magento Enterprise may be a better option. Magento Enterprise offers more advanced customization options, making it a better choice for businesses with complex requirements. It also offers more advanced security options and SEO capabilities.

On the whole, Shopify Plus may be a better choice for online stores that require a more user-friendly, scalable, and cost-effective e-commerce platform and may not have the technical expertise or resources to manage a more complex platform like Magento Enterprise. However, it is important to note that Magento Enterprise may still be a better choice for businesses with complex requirements and larger budgets.

Conclusion for Shopify Plus Vs Magento Enterprise

Ultimately, the decision between Shopify Plus and Magento Enterprise depends on your business needs and budget. It is important to carefully evaluate both platforms and consider factors such as ease of use, scalability, cost, support, integrations, and customization options before deciding.

Shopify Plus seems like the best choice for smaller brands looking to make the jump from a small to medium-sized business to a large-scale one. Large-scale brands, however, may find a better alternative in Magento Commerce, especially when considering highly complex integrations and multiple storefronts. While Shopify Plus can handle multiple storefronts across several regions, brands looking for highly customized storefronts may find Magento the better choice.

Given Shopify Plus’s ease of use, cloud-based solutions, easy integrations, and more cost-effective approach, Shopify Plus gets an edge over the Magento Enterprise cloud. While it’s hard to call Shopify Plus the winner in the Magento Enterprise vs. Shopify Plus discussion, we have to give the edge to Shopify Plus as it’s a much more accessible option for brands looking to scale and large-scale brands alike.

Grow your sales with high-performing deals.

Get PickyStory
  • Topics: Shopify How-To

MOST POPULAR

Back to top

Platform

Main tools

By use case

By industry

Resources

Company

PickyStory is the complete e-commerce upsell platform. PickyStory enables e-commerce brands to make personalized offers by helping customers to discover more products.

pickystory

© All rights reserved 2023

Icon

Not enough sales?

Capture every drop of revenue with PickyStory's complete upsell platform.

Button
pickystory

Get matched with the right partner. PickyStory will do all the work to connect you with one of our awesome partners.

Trusted by the fastest-growing
e-commerce brands

vertical logos
X
pickystory_full_for_black-background-1-min.png

See PickyStory in action

See live demo
pickystory

Convert more visitors into buyers with PickyStory's e-commerce conversion platform

By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from PickyStory.


Trusted by the fastest-growing e-commerce brands

pickystory

Book a demo to learn more about PickyStory's e-commerce upsell platform

By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from PickyStory.


Trusted by the fastest-growing
e-commerce brands

vertical logos